Visualizzazione post con etichetta Wikileaks:i files sul Vaticano. Mostra tutti i post
Visualizzazione post con etichetta Wikileaks:i files sul Vaticano. Mostra tutti i post
0
WikiLeaks Vaticano: USA insiste su "imperativo morale" OGM
Sembra proprio che gli Stati Uniti siano molto interessati alle reti diplomatiche del Vaticano, tanto che non mancano di rivolgersi alla Santa Sede per cercare di risolvere alcune questioni di livello internazionale. E' questo il quadro descritto oggi da "Le Monde" che pubblica altri cablogrammi rilasciati da WikiLeaks che evidenziano tutta l'importanza diplomatica del Vaticano. Per esempio nel 2002 gli USA, durante la seconda Intifada, avrebbero chiesto alla Santa Sede di fare un appello a Yasser Arafat affinché "terminasse le violenze".
Continua a leggere...»
0
Wikileaks: Vaticano ignorante su tecnologia
"La maggior parte dei vertici del Vaticano, tutti uomini in genere sulla settantina, non capiscono i moderni media e la Santa Sede soffre una muddled messaging (confusione nella comunicazione, ndr) a causa della technofobia dei cardinali e l'ignoranza sulle comunicazioni del XXI secolo. Solo il portavoce Federico Lombardi ha un blackberry e pochi una email": lo scrive il numero due dell'ambasciata Usa in Vaticano nel gennaio 2009 in un dispaccio pubblicato dai media partner di Wikileaks, tra i quali il Guardian.
http://www.unionesarda.it/Articoli/News/206351
http://www.unionesarda.it/Articoli/News/206351
0
WIKILEAKS VATICANO – Il Vaticano, secondo i cablogrammi pubblicati da Wikileaks, si sarebbe rifiutato di permettere ai suoi uomini di testimoniare di fronte alla commissione chiamata a fare chiarezza sugli abusi dei sacerdoti su minori in Irlanda. Non solo: il Vaticano si irritò quando fu convocato a Dublino da Roma a questo scopo. Lo rivelano i file di Wikileaks sul Vaticano pubblicati ieri dal Guardian e ripresi da Repubblica. La richiesta di presentarsi di fronte alla commissione Murphy «ha offeso molte persone in Vaticano. Pensano che l'Irlanda non abbia protetto e rispettato la sovranità vaticana durante l'inchiesta», dice un cablogramma uscito su Wikileaks. Il documento in questione è intitolato «Lo scandalo degli abusi sessuali mette a dura prova le relazioni fra l'Irlanda e il Vaticano, scuote la Chiesa irlandese e presenta sfide per la Santa Sede».
http://www.ilsussidiario.net/News/Cronaca/2010/12/11/WIKILEAKS-VATICANO-Gli-Usa-La-Santa-Sede-non-consente-ai-suoi-uomini-di-testimoniare/2/133440/
Gli Usa: La Santa Sede non consente ai suoi uomini di testimoniare
WIKILEAKS VATICANO - Nei cablogrammi inviati a Washington dall'ambasciata americana in Vaticano, si legge inoltre che il Papa sarebbe il responsabile della crescente ostilità nei confronti dell'ingresso della Turchia nell'Unione Europea. Il Vaticano, è scritto, preferirebbe una relazione privilegiata piuttosto che un ingresso a pieno titolo. Ma, come dichiarato all’Agi, il Vaticano invita a considerare che l'attendibilità dei file di Wikileaks che riguardano «rapporti inviati al Dipartimento di Stato degli Stati Uniti d'America dall'Ambasciata degli Stati Uniti presso la Santa Sede». Per il Vaticano infatti «va valutata con riserva e con molta prudenza», tenendo conto, si osserva in una nota, della circostanza che «i rapporti pubblicati da Wikileaks riflettono le percezioni e le opinioni di coloro che li hanno redatti, e non possono essere considerati espressione dello stesso Vaticano né citazioni precise delle parole dei suoi Officiali».
http://www.ilsussidiario.net/News/Cronaca/2010/12/11/WIKILEAKS-VATICANO-Gli-Usa-La-Santa-Sede-non-consente-ai-suoi-uomini-di-testimoniare/2/133440/
0
WIKILEAKS VATICANO – Il Vaticano, secondo i cablogrammi pubblicati da Wikileaks, si sarebbe rifiutato di permettere ai suoi uomini di testimoniare di fronte alla commissione chiamata a fare chiarezza sugli abusi dei sacerdoti su minori in Irlanda.
Continua a leggere...»
WIKILEAKS VATICANO/ Gli Usa: La Santa Sede non consente ai suoi uomini di testimoniare
0
Tutte le questioni sul Vaticano scoperchiate da WikiLeaks
Tralasciando le reazioni della Santa Sede proviamo a mettere ordine, con una specie di rassegna, tra le questioni sollevate dagli ultimi cablogrammi resi pubblici da WikiLeaks e contenenti i rapporti dell’ambasciata Usa presso il Vaticano
Partiamo dai giudizi su Bertone e sulle capacità comunicative della Santa Sede. Il Corriere delle Serariassume tutto brevemente in queste poche righe
Continua a leggere...»
Partiamo dai giudizi su Bertone e sulle capacità comunicative della Santa Sede. Il Corriere delle Serariassume tutto brevemente in queste poche righe
0
Continua a leggere...»
Wikileaks rivela che l’Italia è una diocesi del Vaticano
ROMA - Joaquím Navarro Valls deve appartenere alla categoria di coloro che leggono nel futuro. Non si sa ancora se l’ex portavoce di Giovanni Paolo II, fa parte degli àuguri, o dei divinatori, o dei veggenti, o è semplicemente uno di quei maghi che i cristiani fino al 1782, bruciavano nelle piazze a scopi terapeutici, cioè per liberare la loro anima dal corpo contaminato dal demonio.
0
Wikileaks, i documenti sul Vaticano
L'ambasciata USA stroncava il cardinal Bertone e la capacità di comprensione delle crisi in Vaticano ed esaltava il Blackberry di padre Lombardi
Nel 2001 Ratzinger si opponeva all'ingresso della Turchia nell'Unione Europea
Continua a leggere...»
Nel 2001 Ratzinger si opponeva all'ingresso della Turchia nell'Unione Europea
Nuovi documenti di Wikileaks diffusi venerdì sera riguardano il Vaticano e le relazioni dell’ambasciata degli Stati Uniti in Vaticano. Vi si raccontano molte cose, tra cui le seguenti.
0
Wikileaks mette a nudo il Vaticano: rivelazioni su Turchia e Opus Dei
La lama tagliente sfoderata da Assange e soci non risparmia neanche il Vaticano, Stato che notoriamente non gradisce il gossip, soprattutto quello che lo riguarda direttamente.Nei file pubblicati da Wikileaks scopriamo - riporta il Corriere - che nel 2004, l'allora acrdinale Joseph Ratzinger espresse scetticismo riguardo l'adesione della Turchia all'Unione Europea, distanziandosi, così, dalla posizione di neutralità assunta ufficialmente dal Vaticano.Non mancano i riferimenti alle riunioni organizzate negli ultimi mesi del pontificato di Giovanni Paolo II per risovere la questione "Codice da Vinci", il romanzo di Dan Brown sgradito all'Opus Dei di cui era membro l'allora portavoce vaticano, Navarro Vals. Per il Vaticano, le rivelazioni di Wikileaks "riflettono le opinioni di coloro che li hanno redatti" ma sono pur sempre da considerarsi di "estrema gravità" .
0
21 aprile 2011 - Lo rivela l’ Espresso. Avere il papa dalla propria parte avrebbe evitato contestazioni alle guerre in Kossovo e in Iraq.
L’amministrazione americana ai tempi di George W. Bush voleva arruolare Karol Wojtyla cercando una benedizione per la guerra giusta o quantomeno una neutralità positiva che non avrebbe compromesso i piani di battaglia americani. I dossier segreti ottenuti da Wikileaks, che L‘ Espresso pubblica in esclusiva e di cui ha dato un’anticipazione all’Ansa, rivelano le manovre della diplomazia statunitense negli ultimi anni di Karol Wojtyla. Descrivono la collaborazione del Vaticano durante il conflitto in Kosovo, quando Giovanni Paolo II viene convinto a non denunciare i raid contro la Serbia.Continua a leggere...»
WIKILEAKS: “BUSH VOLEVA ARRUOLARE WOJTYLA
L’amministrazione americana ai tempi di George W. Bush voleva arruolare Karol Wojtyla cercando una benedizione per la guerra giusta o quantomeno una neutralità positiva che non avrebbe compromesso i piani di battaglia americani. I dossier segreti ottenuti da Wikileaks, che L‘ Espresso pubblica in esclusiva e di cui ha dato un’anticipazione all’Ansa, rivelano le manovre della diplomazia statunitense negli ultimi anni di Karol Wojtyla. Descrivono la collaborazione del Vaticano durante il conflitto in Kosovo, quando Giovanni Paolo II viene convinto a non denunciare i raid contro la Serbia.
0
28 aprile 2011 - Un cable di WikiLeaks pubblicato da Repubblica ed Espresso getta luce sull’ atteggiamento delle gerarchie cattoliche nei confronti dei metodi ‘spicci’ degli americani.
Lo scrivono Repubblica e l’ Espresso, citando ancora una volta un cable di Wikileaks che illustra le reazioni del Vaticano nei confronti del lager di Guantanamo. E soprattutto, cosa pensa il Papa della prigione per detenuti che molti hanno definito un lager. Il rapporto dice che la Casa Bianca è preoccupata di avere un largo consenso su Guantanamo, il Vaticano fa resistenze, ma per fortuna c’è un monsignore, entusiasta del pugno di ferro di Bush, pronto a dare informazioni importanti e il suo beneplacito.
Continua a leggere...»
“IL VATICANO APPROVA IL LAGER DI GUANTANAMO”
Lo scrivono Repubblica e l’ Espresso, citando ancora una volta un cable di Wikileaks che illustra le reazioni del Vaticano nei confronti del lager di Guantanamo. E soprattutto, cosa pensa il Papa della prigione per detenuti che molti hanno definito un lager. Il rapporto dice che la Casa Bianca è preoccupata di avere un largo consenso su Guantanamo, il Vaticano fa resistenze, ma per fortuna c’è un monsignore, entusiasta del pugno di ferro di Bush, pronto a dare informazioni importanti e il suo beneplacito.
0

WikiLeaks rivela: Vaticano contra perfidis Judaeis
Notte di Natale. Strani dispacci e comunicati stampa emergono tra le note delle canzoni di Natale, in mezzo a capitoni che devono essere ingurgitati per ringraziare il sole invitto e bambinelli posti a mezzanotte nel Presepe, tra alberi natalizi zeppi di doni e bambini insonnoliti che domattina apriranno i misteriosi regali di Babbo Natale.
Comunicato ANSA: “Il Vaticano, scrive il britannico Guardian, cancellò un accordo scritto per aderire a una associazione nata per promuovere e rafforzare i programmi educativi sulla Shoah a causa delle «tensioni» sul ruolo di Pio XII nel corso della Seconda guerra mondiale. Il numero uno dell’ambasciata Usa presso la Santa Sede, Miguel Diaz, avrebbe stracciato «un accordo scritto» per entrare come «osservatore» nella «Task force for international cooperation on holocaust education», nata nel 1998 per promuovere e rafforzare i programmi educativi sulla Shoah, e alla quale il governo italiano ha aderito nel 1999.”
Ma che sta succedendo ci si chiede, possibile che un membro del Vaticano abbia fatto una cosa del genere? Possibile che la Chiesa cattolica inizi una nuova campagna antisemita, e perché?
Eppure a leggere i dispacci che si sovrappongono sembra tutto vero, e il motivo di tanta rabbia del nunzio apostolico, sarebbe dovuta, secondo le agenzie che riportano i files di WikiLeaks, alla “pubblicazione dei documenti degli archivi vaticani sul periodo di Pio XII” dei quali l’Associazione Shoah avrebbe cercato di anticipare la pubblicazione delle notizie che Giovanni Paolo II aveva ordinato, nel febbraio 2002 di mettere a tacere. In poche parole l’Associazione Shoah voleva rendere subito pubbliche le accuse di antisemitismo nei confronti di Pio XII contenute nei documenti, per fermarne la beatificazione.
Queste rivelazioni di WikiLeaks, pubblicate dal Guardian in effetti confermano, e certificano, ciò che gli osservatori attenti avevano già capito da un pezzo: l’avversione di Ratzinger per gli ebrei e per qualsiasi religione che non sia quella cattolica.
Non è un segreto che Joseph Ratzinger da giovane aveva aderito alla Hitler Jugend, l’organizzazione giovanile diretta emanazione del partito nazionalsocialista tedesco. Tant’è che all’indomani della sua elezione, persino il quotidiano inglese “The Sun” aveva sottolineato, a caratteri cubitali, il passaggio del nuovo Pontefice “from the Hitler Youth to Papa Ratzi”, ”Dalla gioventù hitleriana a Papa Ratzi” pubblicando una grande foto di Benedetto XVI che saluta la folla a San Pietro subito dopo la proclamazione con l’inserto di una foto di Ratzinger nel 1943 vestito da militare tedesco.
Neppure il “Daily Telegraph” fu molto gentile con il pastore tedesco, molto mal visto dai riformati per la sua opera pastorale in seno a quella istituzione che prima si chiamava Santa Inquisizione “Il rottweiler di Dio è il nuovo Papa” titolò il giornale.
“È una esagerazione britannica”, si potrebbe pensare, ma poi ci si ricorda di un altro episodio che fece giustamente infuriare la comunità ebraica: nel 2007 Benedetto XVI con il motu proprio Summorum Pontificium, ripristinò la preghiera del Venerdì Santo contra perfidis Judaeis che recita così: “Preghiamo anche per i perfidi Giudei, affinché il Signore e Dio nostro tolga il velo dai loro cuori in modo che essi riconoscano il Signore nostro Gesù Cristo. Onnipotente ed eterno Dio, che persino la perfidia giudaica non ti repella, esaudisci le nostre preghiere, che ti presentiamo per l’accecamento di quel popolo, affinché venga riconosciuta la luce della tua verità, che è Cristo, a costoro che vagano nelle loro tenebre.” Certo questa preghiera non mette in buona luce i ‘repellenti ebrei che vagano nelle tenebre’. Inoltre non dimentichiamo il discorso di Ratisbona dopo il quale il Vaticano, un po’ come fanno i portavoce del Cavaliere d’Italia, cercò di ritessere i rapporti con il mondo Islamico che si era sentito insultato dalle parole del Papa, dicendo che era stato frainteso.
A quanto pare anche Camus non aveva capito la grandezza di colui che i cattolici vogliono fare santo al più presto, offendendo in questo modo la memoria di milioni di ebrei morti nella shoah.
Il 26 dicembre 1944 Camus, in un articolo apparso su Combat, scriveva a proposito del messaggio di Natale di Papa Pio XII il quale in quell’occasione si era sperticato in lodi per “la vera democrazia, sotto forma repubblicana come sotto forma monarchica”: “Da anni aspettavamo – scrisse Camus – che la massima autorità spirituale del nostro tempo si decidesse a condannare in termini espliciti i misfatti dei dittatori (…) Il nostro auspicio segreto era che la denuncia avvenisse nel momento stesso in cui il male trionfava e in cui le forze del bene si trovavano imbavagliate.(…) Volevamo che la mente dimostrasse la propria forza prima che arrivasse il braccio ad appoggiarla e a darle ragione.(…) Diciamolo chiaramente, avremmo voluto che il Papa prendesse partito nel cuore stesso di quegli anni vergognosi e denunciasse quanto andava denunciato.”
Questo scriveva Camus della Chiesa cattolica che, da Costantino in poi è sempre salita sul carro dei vincitori per spartire con il potere violento ciò che viene rubato al popolo accecato dall’alienazione religiosa.
E la nostra preghiera di Natale, o al sole invitto, sia: che facciano santo chi gli pare ma non infanghino la memoria di milioni di morti ebrei della shoah per proteggere i complici della Gestapo.
0
GIACOMO GALEAZZI
Nella scelta tra difendere l' unita' della Chiesa cristiana o le relazioni della Santa Sede con gli ebrei, in Vaticano vince la prima ''uno a zero'', si legge in un cablogramma dell'ambasciata Usa presso la Santa Sede, pubblicato da Wikileaks. La decisione del Papa di revocare la scomunica ai vescovi Lefebvriani, tra i quali il negazionista Richard Williamson, ''dimostra che la sua maggiore preoccupazione e' il benessere religioso a lungo termine della Chiesa, non le relazioni della Santa sede con gli altri Stati sovrani'', si legge nell'informativa Usa datata 27 gennaio 2009, pochi giorni dopo l' apertura del Vaticano ai vescovi scismatici.'
'Questo atteggiamento 'la religione-prima di tutto' fornisce indicazioni anche sulla pianificazione della Santa Sede del probabile viaggio del Papa in Israele e Giordania il prossimo maggio, e sulla sua gestione della polemica sul fatto se Pio XII possa essere dichiarato santo'', proseguono i diplomatici Usa.'' Secondo membri del Vaticano, questo e' il giusto approccio per un'istituzione di 2000 anni,
WIKILEAKS, PAPA (S)VISTO DA USA
Nella scelta tra difendere l' unita' della Chiesa cristiana o le relazioni della Santa Sede con gli ebrei, in Vaticano vince la prima ''uno a zero'', si legge in un cablogramma dell'ambasciata Usa presso la Santa Sede, pubblicato da Wikileaks. La decisione del Papa di revocare la scomunica ai vescovi Lefebvriani, tra i quali il negazionista Richard Williamson, ''dimostra che la sua maggiore preoccupazione e' il benessere religioso a lungo termine della Chiesa, non le relazioni della Santa sede con gli altri Stati sovrani'', si legge nell'informativa Usa datata 27 gennaio 2009, pochi giorni dopo l' apertura del Vaticano ai vescovi scismatici.'
'Questo atteggiamento 'la religione-prima di tutto' fornisce indicazioni anche sulla pianificazione della Santa Sede del probabile viaggio del Papa in Israele e Giordania il prossimo maggio, e sulla sua gestione della polemica sul fatto se Pio XII possa essere dichiarato santo'', proseguono i diplomatici Usa.'' Secondo membri del Vaticano, questo e' il giusto approccio per un'istituzione di 2000 anni,
che considera il suo piu' grande fallimento 'lo scandalo della disunita' dei Cristiani''. Ma, fa notare l'ambasciata Usa, anche se ''Benedetto XVI ha pubblicamente deplorato l' antisemitismo e sottolineato il miglioramento dei rapporti con gli ebrei'', la gestione ''politicamente stonata'' di questa decisione ''potra' raffreddare l' accoglienza del Papa in Israele''.
0
Cable sobre el embargo a Cuba
Un funcionario vaticano pide a EE UU que relaje el bloqueo contra la isla para evitar un posible baño de sangre
| ID: | 244728 |
| Date: | 2010-01-21 16:21:00 |
| Origin: | 10VATICAN14 |
| Source: | Embassy Vatican |
| Classification: | CONFIDENTIAL |
| Dunno: | 10STATE131637 |
| Destination: | VZCZCXRO4244 PP RUEHDBU RUEHFL RUEHKW RUEHLA RUEHNP RUEHSL RUEHSR DE RUEHROV #0014/01 0211621 ZNY CCCCC ZZH P 211621Z JAN 10 FM AMEMBASSY VATICAN TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 1243 INFO RUEHZL/EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE RUEHUB/USINT HAVANA PRIORITY 0048 RUEHCV/AMEMBASSY CARACAS PRIORITY 0036 RUEHME/AMEMBASSY MEXICO PRIORITY 0043 RUEHBR/AMEMBASSY BRASILIA PRIORITY 0045 RUEHGV/USMISSION GENEVA PRIORITY 0093 RUCNDT/USMISSION USUN NEW YORK PRIORITY 0130 RUEHROV/AMEMBASSY VATICAN 1282 |
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 02 VATICAN 000014 SIPDIS E.O. 12958: DECL: 1/21/2030 TAGS: PGOV, PREL, PHUM, KIRF, CU, VT SUBJECT: VATICAN OFFICIAL ON CUBA RELATIONS WITH EU AND U.S. REF: STATE 131637 VATICAN 00000014 001.2 OF 002 CLASSIFIED BY: Rafael P. Foley, Pol Chief. REASON: 1.4 (b), (d) Summary ------- 1. (C) The Vatican's point person on Cuba, Monsignor Accattino, supports EU dialogue with Cuba and said the U.S. should refrain from unilateral actions against Cuba that play into the hands of the Castros - or Hugo Chavez. This is particularly true, he said, of decisions like identifying Cubans as nationals of particular concern in air travel. The Vatican is concerned that the disastrous economic situation on the island and political tension could lead to bloodshed. Accattino added the "new Fidel Castro" in the Western Hemisphere is Chavez. In a separate meeting, another Vatican official recommended that the U.S. do everything within its power to ensure low rates for Cubans phoning the U.S. End summary. EU Should Engage Cuba --------------------- 2. (C) DCM and polchief met with Accattino on January 14 to discuss USG views on EU dialogue with Cuba (ref. A). Accattino was ambivalent about the pros and cons of a common EU position on Cuba. He said it was important to coordinate approaches, but implied a preference for the soft approach of Spain over that of Poland or the Czech Republic as being more conducive to a positive response from the Cubans. Nevertheless, he conceded that human rights should be part of the agenda in EU dialogue with Cuba and in specific European capitals' individual dialogues with Havana. However, he thought that the island's blatantly poor human rights record should not block engagement with Cuba any more than it does with other rights-abusing nations. After all, he said, the U.S. and the EU engage other countries that violate human rights, like China. U.S. Should Not Be a Hostage to Cuba --------------------------------------- 3. (C) Accattino thought U.S. domestic politics had a counterproductive impact on USG-Cuba policy. As an example, he pointed to the recent USG decision to expand screening of Cubans entering the U.S. by air. Despite being a state sponsor of terrorism, Cuba does not really pose a real threat to the U.S., he said, so the designation was purely for domestic political reasons. Accattino thought this was unjustified, and played into regime hard-liners' portrayal of the U.S. as intrinsically hostile. 4. (C) Looking ahead, Accattino said Cuba's economic and social situations are becoming so bad that people could react violently. If that happens, he added, some in and outside of Cuba could blame the U.S. for having contributed to the situation. The U.S. should not allow itself to be held hostage by domestic politics to maintain the current "counterproductive policy." 5. (C) Moreover, Accattino thought that U.S. policies toward Cuba help Chavez, "who is the true, new successor of Fidel Castro in Latin America." Unlike Fidel, he added, Chavez has oil revenues to support his Bolivarian revolution. Keep Those Phone Rates Low -------------------------- 6. (C) In a separate conversation with the Ambassador on the VATICAN 00000014 002.2 OF 002 margins of a reception on January 15, Monsignor Nicolas Thevenin, the political advisor to Secretary of State Cardinal Bertone, commended the U.S. for allowing U.S. telecommunication companies pursue business in Cuba. Thevenin, who served as a Vatican diplomat in Cuba years ago, continues to follow developments on the island. He hoped the USG could lean on telecommunications companies to make sure that rates for Cubans to call the U.S. would be very low. This, he thought, could have a positive impact in promoting political change. Comment ------- 7. (C) Accattino reiterated the Vatican line about always engaging in dialogue, no matter how unpleasant the interlocutor. He also made it clear that the Vatican is far more concerned about Chavez than Raul Castro, considering him more dangerous and with a longer reach (not to mention younger). For this reason, the Vatican has welcomed recent USG gestures towards Cuba warmly and advocates further USG actions that, the Vatican believes, would make it increasingly difficult for Caracas or Havana to blame Cuba's economic and social failures on Washington. End comment. DIAZ | |
0
Cable sobre el fracaso de la comunicación del Vaticano
La 'número dos' de la Embajada de EE UU repasa los fallos en la estrategia informativa de la Santa Sede
| ID: | 193115 |
| Date: | 2009-02-20 16:00:00 |
| Origin: | 09VATICAN28 |
| Source: | Embassy Vatican |
| Classification: | CONFIDENTIAL |
| Dunno: | 09VATICAN25 |
| Destination: | P 201600Z FEB 09 FM AMEMBASSY VATICAN TO SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 1055 INFO EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE USMISSION GENEVA PRIORITY USMISSION USUN NEW YORK PRIORITY AMEMBASSY BRASILIA PRIORITY AMEMBASSY MEXICO PRIORITY AMEMBASSY BOGOTA PRIORITY AMEMBASSY MANILA PRIORITY AMEMBASSY VATICAN |
C O N F I D E N T I A L VATICAN 000028 E.O. 12958: DECL: 2/20/2029 TAGS: PREL, ECPS, PHUM, PGOV, KPAO, KIRF, VT SUBJECT: THE HOLY SEE: A FAILURE TO COMMUNICATE REF: VATICAN 25 AND PREVIOUS (NOTAL) CLASSIFIED BY: Julieta Valls Noyes, CDA, EXEC, State. REASON: 1.4 (b) 1. (C) Summary: Together with other flaps, the recent global controversy over the lifted excommunication of a Holocaust denying bishop (reftel) exposed a major disconnect between Pope Benedict XVI's stated intentions and the way in which his message is received by the wider world. There are many causes for this communication gap: the challenge of governing a hierarchical yet decentralized organization, leadership weaknesses at the top, and an undervaluing of (and ignorance about) 21st century communications. These factors have led to muddled, reactive messaging that reduces the volume of the moral megaphone the Vatican uses to advance its objectives. This is especially true with audiences whose view of the Vatican is informed largely by mass media coverage. There are signs that at least some in the Vatican have learned their lessons and will work to reshape the Holy See's communications structure. Whether they'll prevail remains to be seen. End Summary. A CENTRALIZED HIERARCHY MAKING DECENTRALIZED DECISIONS --------------------------------------------- --------- 2. (SBU) The Vatican is highly hierarchical with the Pope ultimately responsible for all important matters. Yet it is also highly decentralized in its decision-making. This structure reflects belief in the principle of "subsidiarity": leaving decisions to those closest to, and best informed on, a particular matter. On a practical level, however, subsidiarity can limit horizontal communication by eliminating peer consultation and review. This approach also encourages a narrow focus on issues at the expense of the big picture. 3. (C) In discussing the recent crisis with CDA and PAO, Archbishop Claudio Celli, President of the Pontifical Council for Social Communications, described the Church's current communication style as being focused on the content of a decision, rather than its public impact. Monsignor Paul Tighe, his second in command, noted that this phenomenon is compounded by the fact that officials from the various Church organs see themselves as advocates for their issues, without considering their impact on the Church as a whole. The result is a process in which only a handful of experts are aware of imminent decisions -- even major decisions with broad implications -- and those who are become proponents, rather than impartial advisors to the Pope. 4. (C) A series of missteps during Benedict's Papacy have made the lack of information-sharing in the Church painfully clear. In 2006, the Pope made a speech in Regensburg that was widely decried as insulting to Muslims, though he later explained he had no such intent. In 2008, the Pope himself baptized (i.e., converted)a prominent Muslim during the 2008 Easter Vigil service at St. Peters, an event broadcast worldwide; the Cardinal who runs Inter-Faith Dialogues for the Church knew nothing about the conversion until it happened. This year, Father Federico Lombardi, head of the Vatican press office, and Cardinal Walter Kasper, President of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, which includes relations with Jews, learned only after the fact about the decision to reinstate communion with schismatic Lefebrvist bishops who included a Holocaust denier (reftel). In the midst of that scandal, meanwhile, the Pope proposed promoting to auxiliary bishop a priest who said Hurricane Katrina was "divine retribution" for licentiousness in New Orleans. The resulting outcry led the cleric to decline the offer. A TIN EAR AT THE TOP -------------------- 5. (C) These public missteps have intensified scrutiny of the small group of decision-makers advising the Pope. Normally reserved Vatican commentators have directed withering criticism their way. George Weigel, editor of a conservative US-based Catholic monthly, recently wrote that "curial chaos, confusion, and incompetence" had made clear "how dysfunctional the curia remains in terms of both crisis analysis and crisis management." Secretary of State Tarcisio Bertone -- who is tasked with managing the Curia and is its highest ranking official after the Pope -- has been a particular target. Sandro Magister, a noted Italian journalist, said Cardinal Bertone had "distinguished himself by his absence" during the Lefebrvist controversy, and that the curia had become "more disorganized than before" under his leadership. Yet Magister may have understated the problem. At the height of the Lefebrvist scandal, Bertone referred publicly to the offending bishop by the wrong name, then denounced the media for "inventing" a problem where there was none. Other critics note Bertone's lack of diplomatic experience (he speaks only Italian, for example), and a personal style that elevates "pastoral" work -- with frequent foreign travel focusing on the spiritual needs of Catholics around the world -- over foreign policy and management. 6. (C) More broadly, critics point to a lack of generational or geographical diversity in the Pope's inner circle. Most of the top ranks of the Vatican -- all men, generally in their seventies -- do not understand modern media and new information technologies. The blackberry-using Father Lombardi remains an anomaly in a culture in which many officials do not even have official email accounts. Monsignor Tighe (strictly protect) laid even greater emphasis on the Italo-centric nature of the Pope's closest advisors. Other than Archbishop James Harvey, an American and head of the Papal household, there is no one from an Anglophone country in the Pope's inner circle. Monsignor Tighe, an Irishman, said this meant few had exposure to the American -- or, indeed, global -- rough and tumble of media communications. The Pope's Italian advisors, he said, tend towards old-fashioned, inwardly focused communications written in "coded" language that no-one outside their tight circles can decipher. (The Israeli Ambassador, for example, told CDA that he recently received a Vatican statement that was supposed to contain a positive message for Israel, but it was so veiled he missed it, even when told it was there.) 7. (C) There is also the question of who, if anyone, brings dissenting views to the Pope's attention. As noted, Cardinal Bertone is considered a "yes man," and other Cardinals don't hold much sway with the Pope -- or lack the confidence to bring him bad news. And if bad news rarely filters out, leaks never spring. Monsignor Tighe said that under Pope John Paul II leaks were much more common. While damaging, these leaks did allow time for critics of pending decisions to mobilize and present opposing views to the Pope in time. Pope Benedict and Cardinal Bertone run a much tighter ship, he said, but at the expense of squashing coordination or allow dissenting voices to be heard. NOT SPIN CITY ------------- 8. (C) As has become evident throughout the controversies, much of the Vatican hierarchy greatly undervalues external communication. Structurally, the Pontifical Council for Social Communications and the Vatican Press Office are weak. The former applies the Church's teachings to the field of communications and is not involved in shaping the Pope's message. The latter has the writ, but not the influence. 9. (C) Father Lombardi, the spokesman, is not part of the Pope's inner circle. He has little influence over major decisions, even when he knows about them beforehand. And the poor man is terribly overworked: Lombardi is simultaneously the head of the Vatican Press Office, Vatican Radio (which broadcasts in 45 languages), and the Vatican Television Center, literally moving from one office to the other over the course of the day. It's a grueling schedule on good days, and debilitating during crises. Father Lombardi is the deliverer, rather than a shaper, of the message. In the wake of the Lefebrvist controversy, he openly said that the Vatican press office "didn't control the communication." Without a comprehensive communication strategy in which he plays a central role, he is dependent on individual Church organs and leaders seeking his advice. It's a hit or miss proposition. 10. (C) There is another cost to divorcing decision-making from public spin: the Church's message is often unclear. Monsignor Tighe candidly said that the Holy See rarely considered how best to explain dogmatic, ecclesiastical, moral or other decisions to a broader public. He emphasized that the content of the message should not/not be different -- the Catholic Church would often take positions contrary to public opinion -- but the Church hierarchy needed to think more about how to present positions. CRACKING THE REAL DA VINCI CODE? -------------------------------- 11. (C) The communication culture of the broader Catholic Church is diverse, however, with many Church-affiliated organizations now excelling at communication. One example of a Church organization that is using modern communications strategies to deliver its message, interestingly enough, is Opus Dei. (Pope John Paul II was widely perceived as being more adept at public communications than Benedict; his communications director, Joaquin Navarro Valls, famously belongs to Opus Dei.) CDA and PolOff recently met with Manuel Sanchez, Opus Dei's head of international media relations, and discussed how Opus Dei responded to the "Da Vinci Code" - a novel which pilloried the group. Sanchez said that Opus Dei realized it could respond in one of three ways: (1) ignore the controversy; (2) adopt a `no prisoners' approach and refute every error; or (3) treat the controversy as a chance to explain Opus Dei to the world. Opus Dei chose the third option, holding regular briefings for journalists and others, and the organization's membership has actually increased as a result. FIXING WHAT'S LOST IN TRANSLATION --------------------------------- 12. (C) There is a growing urgency within the Vatican about the need to change the current communication culture. The rare public criticisms offered by Father Lombardi and Cardinal Kasper of their colleagues' roles in the Lefebrvist scandal are an extremely strong indicator of internal disquiet. There are a number of proposals circulating to help fix the problem. Monsignor Tighe and Archbishop Celli have confirmed privately to the Embassy that discussions are underway about having the Pontifical Council for Social Communications assume a greater coordinating role on major decisions. Father Lombardi has privately proposed to his leadership the possibility of creating an office in the Secretariat of State to flag potentially controversial decisions and has asked for resources to prepare translations of major statements more quickly. Other Vatican insiders close to the Pope have suggested bringing more native English speakers into positions in the Pope's inner circle. And not a few voices are calling for Cardinal Bertone's removal from his current position. COMMENT ------- 13. (C) Behind closed doors, our Vatican contacts seems to be talking about nothing but the need for better internal coordination on decisions and planned public messages. Most Church leaders recoil at the notion that they could be seen as anti-Semitic or endorsing Holocaust denials, yet are confronting the ugly reality that many people actually believe these notions because of their own poor communications culture. But if or when change will come remains an open question. The structural and cultural roots of the current situation are deep, and will not be easily uprooted as they are closely connected to Pope Benedict's governing style. Similar criticism after the disastrous Regensburg speech led to little or no change. The percolating discussions regarding the creation of a policy coordinating body within the curia - and other possible solutions -- are hopeful signs. But they are not yet guarantees that change is coming. Stay tuned. End Comment. NOYES | |
0
Cable sobre las relaciones entre EE UU y el Vaticano
La 'número dos' de la Embajada en la Santa Sede afirma que el Vaticano "necesita lecciones en relaciones públicas"
| ID: | 189059 |
| Date: | 2009-01-27 16:52:00 |
| Origin: | 09VATICAN11 |
| Source: | Embassy Vatican |
| Classification: | SECRET |
| Dunno: | 09ROME58 09VATICAN10 09VATICAN9 |
| Destination: | VZCZCXRO6175 PP RUEHFL RUEHKW RUEHLA RUEHNP DE RUEHROV #0011/01 0271652 ZNY SSSSS ZZH P 271652Z JAN 09 FM AMEMBASSY VATICAN TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 1029 INFO RUEHZL/EUROPEAN POLITICAL COLLECTIVE RUEHTV/AMEMBASSY TEL AVIV PRIORITY 0076 RUEHJM/AMCONSUL JERUSALEM PRIORITY 0064 RUEHAM/AMEMBASSY AMMAN PRIORITY 0004 RUEHGV/USMISSION GENEVA PRIORITY 0022 RUCNDT/USMISSION USUN NEW YORK PRIORITY 0030 RUEHROV/AMEMBASSY VATICAN 1065 |
S E C R E T SECTION 01 OF 02 VATICAN 000011 SIPDIS E.O. 12958: DECL: 1/27/2029 TAGS: PGOV, PREL, KIRF, PHUM, JO, IS, VT SUBJECT: CHURCH UNITY ONE, CATHOLIC-JEWISH RELATIONS ZERO REF: A. A) VATICAN 10 B. B) ROME 58 C. C) VATICAN 09 VATICAN 00000011 001.2 OF 002 CLASSIFIED BY: Rafael P. Foley, Acting DCM. REASON: 1.4 (b), (d) 1. (S) Summary: The Pope's decision to reinstate communion with a breakaway Catholic group that included a Holocaust-denying cleric (ref A) proved that his highest concern is the long-term religious well-being of the Church, not the Holy See's relations with other sovereign states. This religion-first attitude is also informing the Holy See's planning for the Pope's probable trip to Israel and Jordan next May (ref B) and its handling of a controversy over whether WWII Pope Pius XII should be declared a saint. Most Holy See insiders believe that this is the right approach for a 2,000 year-old institution which considers its greatest historical failure "the scandal of the Christian disunity." This said, Pope Benedict XVI -- himself a German who lived through WWII -- has publicly deplored anti-Semitism and emphasized improved relations with the Jews. The Holy See may find, however, that its politically tone-deaf handling of this decision may cool the Pope's reception in Israel this May, if the trip is confirmed). End Summary Broad Context, Long History for Vatican-Jewish Dialogue --------------------------------------------- ---------- 2. (C) In a lengthy discussion with CDA and A/DCM on January 23, the Secretary of the Holy See's Commission for Relations with the Jews, Father Norbert Hofmann, described Vatican-Jewish dialogue efforts. He noted that an odd organizational decision demonstrates just how important Catholic-Jewish relations are to the Vatican: the Commission for Relations with Jews comes under the Pontifical Council for the Promotion of Christian Unity -- not/not the Pontifical Council on Inter-Religious Dialogue (which deals with relations with Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists and Animists). According to Hofmann, Jewish leaders appreciate this arrangement because it is to their advantage to underline the special relationship that bounds Christianity to Judaism. 3. (C) Both religions accord major importance to dialogue. Since the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965), the Catholic Church has pursued closer ties with Judaism, citing their shared texts and history. In recent years, and coinciding with the election of German Pope Benedict XVI (who lived through WWII as a child), the effort to strengthen these ties has been kicked into high gear. Jews, Hofmann said, think good relations with the Holy See help combat anti-Semitism and ensure that there will never be another Shoa. Denial of Outrage about Perceived Affronts ------------------------------------------ 4. (C) Hofmann opined that Pope Benedict XVI's reinstatement of the four Lefebvrist clerics excommunicated by Pope John Paul II (ref a) would not damage Vatican relations with the Jews over the long term. He anticipated that the public denial of the Holocaust by one of the four, Bishop Williamson, would be controversial and would attract criticism in the short term but then be set aside quickly. Other Church leaders seemed to agree that since the Pope's decision was religious, not political, it would be understood as such. The head of the French bishops' conference, for example, hailed the act as "a gesture of mercy and openness for strengthening Church unity." Other Church leaders disassociated themselves from Bishop Williamson's Holocaust denials, then adding words of welcome for the reinstatement of the four Lefebvrists. It fell mostly to Cardinal Kasper, who runs the Catholic-Jewish dialogue, to condemn the rehabilitated bishop's remarks as "stupid" and "unacceptable," and having "nothing to do with the Catholic Church." As is typical, the Pope stayed above the fray and did not comment. 5. (S) Indeed, most Church leaders seem to think the damage from this matter will not last or harm the Pope's planned visit to Israel. Father Hofmann specifically said the controversy would join other similar matters as "non-issues in the good state of Jewish-Catholic relations." Nevertheless, other controversies continue to rankle with Jews and others. Among them is an old Latin Catholic Mass prayer calling for conversion of Jews. Even more controversial in recent months has been the proposal to canonize (make a saint of) Pope Pius XII, the WWII-era Pope who some criticize for not having publicly denounced the Holocaust. Rabbi Cohen of Haifa (Israel), the first Rabbi ever invited to address a Synod of bishops, implicitly criticized the canonization proposal in his remarks to the bishops last fall. Church officials did not expect the criticism and were annoyed by it. Hofmann dismissed even those public remarks, though, saying the Rabbi had confided in him that he'd been pressured by other Jewish leaders to deliver the point. VATICAN 00000011 002.2 OF 002 Prospects for Pope's Trip to Israel and Jordan --------------------------------------------- - 6. (C) Meanwhile, the Pope's planned visit to Israel looms large in Vatican-Jewish relations. Consistent with what other Vatican officials have told us (ref b), Father Hofmann confirmed that the Pope's trip was not conditioned on resolving Church property taxation issues in the Israel-Holy See Fundamental Agreement. The real motivation for the trip is, again, religious: the eighty-one year-old Pope wants to make a pilgrimage to the Holy Land as Pontiff before his advanced age makes it too difficult. At the same time, the Holy See believes the Pope's trip to Israel, the West Bank and Jordan will advance awareness about the Holocaust and the need to combat anti-Semitism. A Papal visit will also publicly highlight the Vatican's acceptance of the State of Israel, with which the Holy See established relations in 1993. Hofmann implied that for these reasons, absent major negative developments, the trip would occur. 7. (S) In a separate conversation on January 23, the new Israeli Ambassador to the Holy See, Mordechai Lewy, took a somewhat more jaded view. While confirming that planning without pre-conditions is underway, expressing hope that the trip would happen, and acknowledging that it could advance Catholic-Jewish dialogue, Lewy would not speculate on its likelihood. Lewy did not see many prospects for a Papal visit helping to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. While Israel wants to keep on good terms with the Holy See to avoid problems, he said, Israeli leaders don't think that the Vatican can influence the Arabs. 8. (S) On the other hand, Lewy said, the Jordanians may have a pecuniary interest in the visit. Prince Ghazi, Lewy alleged, has financial stakes in the possible tourist development of the area around Jesus' baptismal site. A Papal visit to this area would be good for business. Since not all churches in that area would welcome such development, this has caused some conflict between authorities and local churches. 9. (C) The Israeli Ambassador did not think that the recent Gaza crisis would play a role in the Pope's final decision on whether to travel to the Holy Land. Lewy was disappointed with the Vatican's criticism of Israeli actions in Gaza, and raised his views with Monsignor Parolin, the Holy See's deputy foreign minister. Lewy urged Parolin to say something positive about Israel to balance these remarks. Specifically, he wanted the Holy See to state publicly that the religious freedom Christians enjoy in Israel is unparalleled in the Middle East, where Christian minorities are increasingly on the defensive against political Islam. Parolin, he said, committed to do so. (C) Comment: A Formidable Partner in Need of P.R. Lessons --------------------------------------------- ------------ 10. (S) Pope Benedict sometimes bewilders politicians and journalists by pursuing what he believes is in the best interest of the Church, such as reinstating the Lefebvrists or considering the canonization of Pius XII. (His predecessor, John Paul II, suffered from some of the same second-guessing.) Vatican outsiders lament decisions or policies that they perceive as being out-of-step with the new millennium, and call for the Church to be more modern and accommodating. What these observers fail to recognize is the consistency of the Holy See's decisions and behavior on key issues like the reunification of the Church or the dignity of all human beings - and the value of that consistency. Regardless of whether outsiders agree or disagree with the Holy See, it's hard to dispute its moral influence, geographic reach, and ability to grab headlines. These qualities can make the Vatican a formidable partner for the U.S. and other nations in the pursuit of common objectives. 11. (S) At the same time, there's no denying the fact that a little more attention to how the outside world views decisions taken inside the Church could help the Holy See protect its image and further its influence. Although Church leaders like Benedict are adopting new means of communication to get their message to a wider audience (ref C), they have not yet embraced fully the need -- and tools -- for 21st century public relations. The Holy See's spokesmen could have resoundingly denounced the Holocaust-denying views of Bishop Williamson at the same time the Pope welcomed him back into the Church, but they waited days to do so, and then did it weakly. By then, much of the damage had been done. Instead of scoring a religious hat-trick -- reuniting the Church, demonstrating the Church's commitment to second chances for those who have erred, and reaffirming the horrors of the Holocaust -- the Holy See is playing catch-up. End Comment. JVNOYES | |
Iscriviti a:
Post (Atom)






